Home / News

Oregon Bill Targets Faith-Healing Parents

House Unanimously OKs Legislation; Senate Next

POSTED: 4:32 pm PST March 10, 2011
The Oregon House unanimously approved a bill Thursday that would remove legal protections for parents who refuse medical treatment and rely solely on faith to heal their dying children.

Lawmakers approved the measure on a 59-0 vote, sending it to the Senate.

The measure targets an Oregon City church with a history of children dying after their parents refused secular medicine in favor of religious rituals such as prayer or anointing the sick with oil.

The bill sponsored by Democratic Rep. Carolyn Tomei of Milwaukie would eliminate faith healing as a defense for murder charges.

It follows a 1999 measure that eliminated the faith healing defense from some charges of manslaughter, criminal mistreatment and nonpayment of child support.

---

News release from the Oregon House Democratic Caucus:

House Passes Bill Eliminating Spiritual Treatment as a Defense for Crimes against Children

SALEM – The Oregon House of Representatives today passed HB 2721, eliminating the reliance on spiritual treatment as a defense for crimes against children. HB 2721 repeals the remaining religious exemptions for parents or guardians pertaining to medical care of sick children.

State Representatives Carolyn Tomei and Dave Hunt, both from Clackamas County, are chief co-sponsors of the bill, along with Representative Mitch Greenlick. Other sponsors include Representatives Jeff Barker, Margaret Doherty, Lew Frederick, Sara Gelser, Chris Harker and Tobias Read. The bill passed unanimously.

“Children are suffering and dying from easily treatable illnesses,” said Rep. Tomei (D-Milwaukie). “When you visit the graveyard and see all those children’s names, it’s time to say enough is enough.”

In recent cases out of Clackamas County, two children have died and another was seriously disfigured. Each of these children had treatable medical conditions, but their parents did not seek treatment, instead relying solely on spiritual remedies.

“As someone who has fought for years to expand religious freedoms, I believe we cannot allow children in our community to die or suffer needlessly because their parents refuse to treat them when proper medical treatment is just around the corner,” said Rep. Hunt (D- Clackamas).

“This bill is about protecting kids, not punishing parents. My hope is that this bill will prevent a child from being denied medical care by their parents week after week, despite the fact that the child is in dire need of medical attention,” said Rep. Greenlick (D-Portland/Washington County).

The last changes to our laws came in 1999. Along with Clackamas County District Attorney John Foote, Rep. Tomei and Rep. Hunt have crafted this measure to hold all parents to the same standard of care for their children and protect all children equally.

The bill is supported by the Oregon District Attorney Association, the Oregon Medical Association and many more. It now goes to the Senate for approval.
The views expressed are not those of KTVZ.com, KTVZ or its affiliated companies. This is a community moderated forum. (Please note the 'Like' and 'Report' buttons.) By posting your comments you agree to accept our Terms of Use.

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Advertiser Links

Most Popular

E-Mail Sign-up

E - News Registration
 6 a.m. Local Alert Weather
6 p.m. Local Alert Weather
Local Breaking News
National Breaking News
Noon Headlines
8 p.m. Headlines
9 a.m. Headlines
4 p.m. Headlines
7 a.m. Headlines